what dog is the most protective bettween rottweiler, doberman, german shepard?

[john h]

people think i am going to treat my dog badly and use it to be aggressive well they are wrong i just want a protective dog sometimes if a bad guy breaks in a golden retriever isnt going to help fight the guy so i want a dog protective smart strong fast and kind and that looks cool

[suzannestone]

I had a german Shepherd for 13 years and he was the softest most loving dog you could imagine. Then one day a sales man came round and started to pester my mum into buying something, she didn't want anything and he refused to go, anyway max growled and went for this guy (which is what the a***hole deserved!) My mom was on her own that day and she said she felt 100 times safer because max had been with her that day! I would recommend a german Shepherd anyday!!!!

[xxleah9153]

Its funny because my one dog is a mix between all of them and she cant get anymore protective and i have a full bred shepherd and she too is also veryyy protective... it causes some problems bc i have to have them in cages when people come over bc if the person gets to close my dogs will bite..

[mmcrobinson]

Not any that you listed - should be the other way around. You protecting them

[Ariel]

You should use means other than an animal to protect your home. It doesn't matter what the breed is any dog can scare off burglars. Even a chihuahua can kill someone.

[kelsey h]

i would say rott. we raised them and german shepards and i loved the rotts. they are really sweet around people they live with if you treat them right and are really protective over you.

[Sunshine]

I think all 3 of them are good ones for that.

[DOG1]

german shepard if you have kids
rottweiler if your a loner

[Stacy]

If a bad guy comes in and your dog tries to defend it's home, the bad guy is going to shoot the dog and kill it. It happens very often. Do not get a dog for protection, get a dog based on the temperment and activity levels that suit you.

[lilmee]

Originally Posted by john h

people think i am going to treat my dog badly and use it to be aggressive well they are wrong i just want a protective dog sometimes if a bad guy breaks in a golden retriever isnt going to help fight the guy so i want a dog protective smart strong fast and kind and that looks cool

I would say a shepard. But really it depends on the individual dogs temperment and how they are raised.